The criteria are yours to name but please do so for clarity. If its solely presentation (AQ/PQ), fine, if its solely quality of the actual film fine, if its a combination, great too. Maybe a running list will be useful to other members making rent/purchase decisions. My criteria is a combination of how much I liked the movie and how good the PQ/SQ was. My list, in no particular order would be. Hot Fuzz (HD-DVD) Apocalypto (BD) The Prestige (BD) 300 (either format, and don't talk to me about grain) Corpse Bride (BD) Seabuscuit (HD-DVD) Transformers (HD-DVD) Stardust (HD-DVD) Bridge to Terabithia (BD) The Last Samurai (HD-DVD) Best older film transfer/restoration goes to Blade Runner IMO (again, including in the criteria how much I like the film). This is a personal list obviously, and there are other good looking films which I haven't seen (I haven't seen the 2nd release of The 5th Element for example) because I've seen the film enough times that I wasn't in mood to rent/buy it just to see the new transfer. So what is your list?